Fair point.

[no arguments - although if Curufin drops in on him, he'll get his chance either way]

I've only crossed paths with the guy once, and I didn't get a good read on him. I can't say if he's the type to even feel remorse. If you're going to go after him, at least do it at full strength.

[at which thought his hand unconsciously crosses to grip his right arm at the point of the scar plainly visible below his shirtsleeve]