The disbelief isn't unexpected. Girl didn't believe it either at first. It was time that made it settle in for her. And, if she were being honest, the appearance of her friend. So Girl's prepared to be sympathetic, point the woman toward others who could explain things better and maybe make this seem a little more real. But-

"Me? I didn't do this!" Sympathy flies out the window and indignation takes its place. "I'm stuck here the same as you. The wannabe gods are the ones to blame, not me."