Carlisle seems so excited for a second; his mouth widens into a toothy grin, a chuckle escaping him. Unfortunately, he doesn't have time to even question whether or not Rey is teasing him, his expression faltering at a single word. Gone is his smile, his shoulders stiffening as his brows furrow in alarm.

"W- no no no, I'm not- I'm not a wizard!" He pulls his mug to him, as though shielding it from the very notion. "Why- why would you say that? That's not- that's not what wizards do!"