[ THey can fish later and Maglor can try and charm some fish out of the water for him? ]

Ah! That is an innovation none of us had considered. But a bit too complicated for now, I think.

[ He nods ] If the material is good enough, it should be easy enough to melt down and reforge. Curufin or Celebrimbor would be the best to ask though - I fear I neglected much of my forge-studies. It never sang to me as it did to my brother or my nephew.