So it is. [ And as for the Silmaril, Maglor would know, since he was the one who threw it in. Whether it is still sunk in the muck at the bottom of the bay or retrieved by Ulmo or one of his Maiar and cached in some underwater palace, it would still have power over Maglor's imagination. ]

It is true, Nelyo and Findekáno were exhausted by their losses, and Nelyo in particular was overcome by his memories. I would think you are right, they are still at home or nearby. It would be good if you would call them.